Get Free Quotes
Home
/
Resources
/
Comparisons
Comparisons

Square vs. PayPal: Fees, Features and Which to Choose

A side-by-side comparison of Square and PayPal fees, where each one costs less, and which fits your business.

By
PaymentNinja Team
·
4
min read
·
November 12, 2026

Square and PayPal are both popular ways to accept card payments, but they suit different businesses. Square is built for retail, food and service businesses starting out; PayPal is built for online sellers whose customers like paying with PayPal. Here's how their published US rates compare, using pricing we checked in November 2026.

Fees side by side

FeeSquarePayPal
Pricing modelFlat rateFlat rate
In-person card2.6% + 10¢2.29% + 9¢
Online card2.9% + 30¢2.99% + 49¢ (cards)
Keyed-in card3.5% + 15¢2.99% + 49¢
Monthly fee$0 on the free plan$0
Chargeback feeNot listed on Square's fee page$20
Other feesInvoices and payment links 3.3% + 30¢; invoice ACH 1% ($1 minimum). Custom pricing may be available above $250,000 a year.PayPal Checkout and Venmo 3.49% + 49¢; Advanced card payments 2.89% + 29¢ or interchange + 0.49% + 39¢; international transactions +1.5%.

Which is cheaper?

In person, PayPal is cheaper on every sale size. For example, on a $20 sale Square costs $0.62 and PayPal $0.55; on a $200 sale Square costs $5.30 and PayPal $4.67.

In person, PayPal is cheaper at all three monthly volumes below.

Monthly volume (in person)SquarePayPal
$5,000$140$124
$25,000$700$618
$100,000$2,800$2,470

Online, Square is cheaper on every sale size. For example, on a $20 sale Square costs $0.88 and PayPal $1.09; on a $200 sale Square costs $6.10 and PayPal $6.47.

Online, Square is cheaper at all three monthly volumes below.

Monthly volume (online)SquarePayPal
$5,000$175$199
$25,000$875$993
$100,000$3,500$3,970

Run your own numbers with our processing fee calculator.

Biggest strengths and drawbacks

  • Square: Free POS software and simple hardware. The main drawback: keyed-in payments are expensive.
  • PayPal: Highly recognized checkout brand. The main drawback: higher online fees, especially the 49¢ fixed fee.

Which suits your business?

  • Choose Square if your business fits: retail, food and service businesses starting out. See our Square review.
  • Choose PayPal if your business fits: online sellers whose customers like paying with PayPal. See our PayPal review.

Still deciding? See the best Square alternatives and PayPal alternatives, or our guide to flat-rate vs. interchange-plus pricing.

What about high-risk businesses?

Mainstream providers review accounts after signup and may restrict some industries, so businesses in categories like CBD, supplements, travel or subscriptions can be approved and then frozen later. If that applies to you, read what makes a business high-risk. A dedicated merchant account, such as one from Zeyla, is underwritten before approval (PaymentNinja has a partner relationship with Zeyla; see our disclosure).

Rates are standard published US pricing checked November 2026 and can change. Monthly examples assume a $50 average sale. Confirm current pricing on each provider's site before you sign up.

Free quotes · No obligation

Get matched with the right processor

Two quick steps. We'll share your request with processing partners that fit your industry and volume, including high-risk specialists.

✓ Free for businesses
✓ High-risk industries welcome
✓ Compare offers before you commit
Step 1 of 2 · About your business
Please choose your industry and monthly sales.
Next: get my quotes →
Step 2 of 2 · Where should partners send quotes?
← Back
Thanks! Your request is in. A payments specialist from one of our partners will contact you about a quote.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.