Get Free Quotes
Home
/
Resources
/
Comparisons
Comparisons

The Best Square Alternatives in 2026

8 Square alternatives compared on fees, monthly costs and who each one suits.

By
PaymentNinja Team
·
4
min read
·
November 12, 2026

Square is a solid choice for retail, food and service businesses starting out, but it isn't right for everyone. The most common reasons businesses look elsewhere: keyed-in payments are expensive; flat rates add up at higher volumes; restricts some industries; possible holds. Here are 8 alternatives, with published US pricing we checked in November 2026.

Square alternatives at a glance

ProviderOnline cardIn-person cardMonthly feeBest for
Square (current)2.9% + 30¢2.6% + 10¢$0 on the free planRetail, food and service businesses starting out
Stripe2.9% + 30¢2.7% + 5¢$0Online stores, SaaS and platforms
PayPal2.99% + 49¢ (cards)2.29% + 9¢$0Online sellers whose customers like paying with PayPal
Shopify Payments2.5%–2.9% + 30¢ (by plan)2.4%–2.6% + 10¢ (by plan)$29–$299/mo Shopify plan (billed annually)Online stores already selling on Shopify
HelcimInterchange + 0.50% + 25¢Interchange + 0.40% + 8¢$0Growing businesses that want lower, transparent rates
Authorize.net2.9% + 30¢ (All-in-One)2.9% + 30¢ (All-in-One)$25Businesses that already have (or need) a separate merchant account
StaxInterchange + 15¢Interchange + 8¢$99–$199+/mo (by annual volume)Businesses processing $10,000+ a month that want wholesale card rates
Braintree2.89% + 29¢Not offeredNot listedOnline businesses that want cards, PayPal and Venmo in one integration
Payment DepotInterchange + quoted markupInterchange + quoted markup$0 (plus $10/mo PCI fee)Small businesses that want interchange-plus pricing without a contract

The alternatives

1. Stripe

Flat-rate online payments with excellent developer tools and no monthly fee.

Compared with Square: At $25,000 a month in in-person card sales, Stripe and Square cost about the same ($700 a month).

Best for: Online stores, SaaS and platforms. Read our Stripe review or the full Stripe vs. Square comparison.

2. PayPal

Widely recognized checkout with in-person options, but higher online fees than most.

Compared with Square: At $25,000 a month in in-person card sales, PayPal costs about $618 a month versus $700 with Square.

Best for: Online sellers whose customers like paying with PayPal. Read our PayPal review or the full Square vs. PayPal comparison.

3. Shopify Payments

Shopify's own processor: no extra setup, rates fall as your Shopify plan goes up.

Compared with Square: At $25,000 a month in in-person card sales, Shopify Payments costs about $729–$949 a month versus $700 with Square.

Best for: Online stores already selling on Shopify. Read our Shopify Payments review or the full Square vs. Shopify Payments comparison.

4. Helcim

Transparent interchange-plus pricing with automatic volume discounts and no monthly fee.

Compared with Square: At $25,000 a month in in-person card sales, Helcim charges interchange + about $140, so it beats Square ($700) whenever your average interchange is below 2.24%.

Best for: Growing businesses that want lower, transparent rates. Read our Helcim review or the full Square vs. Helcim comparison.

5. Authorize.net

A widely supported gateway that can connect to your own merchant account, including high-risk accounts.

Compared with Square: At $25,000 a month in in-person card sales, Authorize.net costs about $900 a month versus $700 with Square.

Best for: Businesses that already have (or need) a separate merchant account. Read our Authorize.net review or the full Square vs. Authorize.net comparison.

6. Stax

Pay a flat monthly subscription and get card processing at interchange cost plus a few cents.

Compared with Square: At $25,000 a month in in-person card sales, Stax charges interchange + about $239, so it beats Square ($700) whenever your average interchange is below 1.84%.

Best for: Businesses processing $10,000+ a month that want wholesale card rates. Read our Stax review or the full Square vs. Stax comparison.

7. Braintree

A developer-focused gateway from PayPal that accepts cards, PayPal and Venmo.

Compared with Square: Braintree doesn't offer in-person processing, so it only replaces Square for online sales.

Best for: Online businesses that want cards, PayPal and Venmo in one integration. Read our Braintree review or the full Square vs. Braintree comparison.

8. Payment Depot

Interchange-plus processing with a quoted markup, no monthly subscription and no long-term contract.

Compared with Square: Payment Depot quotes its markup per business, so ask for a written quote and compare it with your current Square statement.

Best for: Small businesses that want interchange-plus pricing without a contract. Read our Payment Depot review or the full Square vs. Payment Depot comparison.

If Square closed or restricted your account

Switching to another instant-signup provider often repeats the problem, because most mainstream providers review accounts after signup and restrict many of the same industries. A dedicated merchant account is underwritten before approval instead. Zeyla is one option: a specialist reviews every application, and Zeyla says it replies within 2 business days (PaymentNinja has a partner relationship with Zeyla; see our disclosure). See also what makes a business high-risk.

How to choose

Rates are standard published US pricing checked November 2026 and can change. Examples assume a $50 average sale. Confirm current pricing on each provider's site before you sign up.

Free quotes · No obligation

Get matched with the right processor

Two quick steps. We'll share your request with processing partners that fit your industry and volume, including high-risk specialists.

✓ Free for businesses
✓ High-risk industries welcome
✓ Compare offers before you commit
Step 1 of 2 · About your business
Please choose your industry and monthly sales.
Next: get my quotes →
Step 2 of 2 · Where should partners send quotes?
← Back
Thanks! Your request is in. A payments specialist from one of our partners will contact you about a quote.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.