Shopify Payments is a solid choice for online stores already selling on Shopify, but it isn't right for everyone. The most common reasons businesses look elsewhere: only works with a Shopify store; flat rates can be costly at high volume; restricts many high-risk products. Here are 8 alternatives, with published US pricing we checked in November 2026.
Shopify Payments alternatives at a glance
| Provider | Online card | In-person card | Monthly fee | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shopify Payments (current) | 2.5%–2.9% + 30¢ (by plan) | 2.4%–2.6% + 10¢ (by plan) | $29–$299/mo Shopify plan (billed annually) | Online stores already selling on Shopify |
| Stripe | 2.9% + 30¢ | 2.7% + 5¢ | $0 | Online stores, SaaS and platforms |
| Square | 2.9% + 30¢ | 2.6% + 10¢ | $0 on the free plan | Retail, food and service businesses starting out |
| PayPal | 2.99% + 49¢ (cards) | 2.29% + 9¢ | $0 | Online sellers whose customers like paying with PayPal |
| Helcim | Interchange + 0.50% + 25¢ | Interchange + 0.40% + 8¢ | $0 | Growing businesses that want lower, transparent rates |
| Authorize.net | 2.9% + 30¢ (All-in-One) | 2.9% + 30¢ (All-in-One) | $25 | Businesses that already have (or need) a separate merchant account |
| Braintree | 2.89% + 29¢ | Not offered | Not listed | Online businesses that want cards, PayPal and Venmo in one integration |
| Stax | Interchange + 15¢ | Interchange + 8¢ | $99–$199+/mo (by annual volume) | Businesses processing $10,000+ a month that want wholesale card rates |
| Payment Depot | Interchange + quoted markup | Interchange + quoted markup | $0 (plus $10/mo PCI fee) | Small businesses that want interchange-plus pricing without a contract |
The alternatives
1. Stripe
Flat-rate online payments with excellent developer tools and no monthly fee.
Compared with Shopify Payments: At $25,000 a month in online card sales, Stripe costs about $875 a month versus $904–$1,074 with Shopify Payments.
Best for: Online stores, SaaS and platforms. Read our Stripe review or the full Stripe vs. Shopify Payments comparison.
2. Square
Easy flat-rate processing with free POS software, ideal for small in-person sellers.
Compared with Shopify Payments: At $25,000 a month in online card sales, Square costs about $875 a month versus $904–$1,074 with Shopify Payments.
Best for: Retail, food and service businesses starting out. Read our Square review or the full Square vs. Shopify Payments comparison.
3. PayPal
Widely recognized checkout with in-person options, but higher online fees than most.
Compared with Shopify Payments: At $25,000 a month in online card sales, PayPal costs about $993 a month versus $904–$1,074 with Shopify Payments.
Best for: Online sellers whose customers like paying with PayPal. Read our PayPal review or the full PayPal vs. Shopify Payments comparison.
4. Helcim
Transparent interchange-plus pricing with automatic volume discounts and no monthly fee.
Compared with Shopify Payments: At $25,000 a month in online card sales, Helcim charges interchange + about $250, so it beats Shopify Payments ($904–$1,074) whenever your average interchange is below 2.62% to 3.3%.
Best for: Growing businesses that want lower, transparent rates. Read our Helcim review or the full Shopify Payments vs. Helcim comparison.
5. Authorize.net
A widely supported gateway that can connect to your own merchant account, including high-risk accounts.
Compared with Shopify Payments: At $25,000 a month in online card sales, Authorize.net costs about $900 a month versus $904–$1,074 with Shopify Payments.
Best for: Businesses that already have (or need) a separate merchant account. Read our Authorize.net review or the full Shopify Payments vs. Authorize.net comparison.
6. Braintree
A developer-focused gateway from PayPal that accepts cards, PayPal and Venmo.
Compared with Shopify Payments: At $25,000 a month in online card sales, Braintree costs about $868 a month versus $904–$1,074 with Shopify Payments.
Best for: Online businesses that want cards, PayPal and Venmo in one integration. Read our Braintree review or the full Shopify Payments vs. Braintree comparison.
7. Stax
Pay a flat monthly subscription and get card processing at interchange cost plus a few cents.
Compared with Shopify Payments: At $25,000 a month in online card sales, Stax charges interchange + about $274, so it beats Shopify Payments ($904–$1,074) whenever your average interchange is below 2.52% to 3.2%.
Best for: Businesses processing $10,000+ a month that want wholesale card rates. Read our Stax review or the full Shopify Payments vs. Stax comparison.
8. Payment Depot
Interchange-plus processing with a quoted markup, no monthly subscription and no long-term contract.
Compared with Shopify Payments: Payment Depot quotes its markup per business, so ask for a written quote and compare it with your current Shopify Payments statement.
Best for: Small businesses that want interchange-plus pricing without a contract. Read our Payment Depot review or the full Shopify Payments vs. Payment Depot comparison.
If Shopify Payments closed or restricted your account
Switching to another instant-signup provider often repeats the problem, because most mainstream providers review accounts after signup and restrict many of the same industries. A dedicated merchant account is underwritten before approval instead. Zeyla is one option: a specialist reviews every application, and Zeyla says it replies within 2 business days (PaymentNinja has a partner relationship with Zeyla; see our disclosure). See also what makes a business high-risk.
How to choose
- Selling mostly in person? Prioritize in-person rates and POS hardware.
- Processing more than about $10,000 a month? Interchange-plus or subscription pricing often costs less than a flat rate. Read flat-rate vs. interchange-plus pricing.
- Ready to move? Follow our guide to switching payment processors and run your numbers in the processing fee calculator.
Rates are standard published US pricing checked November 2026 and can change. Examples assume a $50 average sale. Confirm current pricing on each provider's site before you sign up.