Get Free Quotes
Home
/
Resources
/
Fees & Pricing
Fees & Pricing

Card-Present vs. Card-Not-Present Transactions: Why Rates Differ

Why online, keyed and phone payments cost more to process than in-person payments, and practical ways to lower your card-not-present costs.

By
PaymentNinja Team
·
5
min read
·
November 3, 2026

Look at almost any processor's pricing page and you'll see two sets of rates: one for payments taken in person and a higher one for payments taken online, over the phone or keyed in by hand. The difference comes down to one thing: how sure everyone in the payment chain can be that the real cardholder is making the purchase.

What counts as card-present

A transaction is card-present when the physical card (or a phone or watch holding a digital version of it) interacts with a payment terminal. That includes tapping a contactless card, inserting a chip card, swiping a magnetic stripe, or paying with a mobile wallet at a terminal.

A transaction is card-not-present (CNP) when the card details are sent without the card being read by a terminal. That covers:

  • Online checkout on a website or in an app
  • Card numbers typed into a virtual terminal for phone or mail orders
  • Payment links and invoices paid online
  • Recurring charges to a card stored on file
  • Card numbers keyed into a physical terminal because the chip or stripe couldn't be read

The last one surprises many business owners: even if the customer is standing at your counter, a manually keyed card is usually priced as card-not-present because the terminal never verified the card itself.

Why card-not-present costs more

1. Fraud risk is higher

When a chip card is inserted or tapped, the card generates data that's very hard to copy, which makes counterfeit fraud difficult. Online, a fraudster only needs stolen card details. Card issuers set interchange (the wholesale fee they receive on each transaction) higher for categories with more fraud risk, and most card-not-present categories carry higher interchange than comparable in-person ones.

2. Liability often sits with the merchant

If a cardholder disputes an online transaction as fraudulent, the merchant frequently bears the loss through a chargeback. Processors price that risk into their rates, which is part of why aggregators with a single flat rate charge more for online payments.

3. More tools are needed to verify the buyer

Online payments rely on extra checks, such as the card security code, address verification and authentication programs like 3-D Secure. Those services cost money to run, and some providers charge for them separately.

What the difference looks like in practice

Here are a few published US rates, checked on each provider's website on 3 November 2026:

ProviderIn personOnlineKeyed
Stripe2.7% + 5¢2.9% + 30¢Online rate + 0.5%
Square2.6% + 10¢From 2.9% + 30¢3.5% + 15¢
Helcim (up to $50K/month)Interchange + 0.40% + 8¢Interchange + 0.50% + 25¢Interchange + 0.50% + 25¢
StaxInterchange + 8¢Interchange + 15¢Interchange + 15¢

Notice that the gap shows up in two places. The percentage is often higher for card-not-present payments, and the fixed per-transaction fee is usually much higher too. On a $10 sale, a 30¢ fixed fee alone is 3% of the transaction, so the fixed fee matters most for businesses with small average tickets. On interchange-plus pricing, the interchange itself is also typically higher for card-not-present transactions, on top of the provider's markup.

How to lower your card-not-present costs

Move payments in person where it makes sense

If customers visit your location to collect an order, consider taking payment on a terminal at collection instead of over the phone. If staff regularly key in cards because the chip reader fails, replace or repair the terminal; keyed transactions are one of the most avoidable costs on many statements.

Use payment links instead of reading card numbers aloud

Phone orders keyed into a virtual terminal are among the most expensive transactions. A payment link sent by text or email is still card-not-present, but it lets the customer enter their own details, can support extra verification, and avoids staff handling card numbers. Compare the link rate with your keyed rate first, because some providers price them differently.

Offer bank payments for large invoices

For business-to-business invoices, ACH bank transfers are usually far cheaper than cards. For example, Square lists invoice ACH payments at 1% with a $1 minimum, and Stripe lists ACH Direct Debit at 0.8% capped at $5. On a large invoice, that difference can be significant.

Send complete transaction data

Online, make sure your checkout sends the billing address and security code with each transaction. Missing data can lead to higher fraud risk and, with some providers and card types, higher costs. Ask your provider which data fields your integration sends.

Use authentication where it helps

Authentication tools such as 3-D Secure add a step for the customer, but they can shift liability for certain fraud disputes away from the merchant. Many providers let you apply authentication selectively, for example only to higher-value or higher-risk orders.

Consider interchange-plus pricing as volume grows

On flat-rate pricing, you pay the same high online rate whether a customer uses a low-cost debit card or a premium rewards card. On interchange-plus pricing, you pay the actual interchange plus a markup, so lower-cost transactions cost you less. Read flat-rate vs. interchange-plus vs. tiered pricing to see which model fits your volume.

Card-not-present and chargebacks

Because card-not-present payments carry more fraud risk, they also tend to generate more chargebacks. Clear product descriptions, a billing descriptor customers recognize, prompt delivery tracking and an easy refund process all help. Read chargebacks explained for a full prevention checklist, and track your rate with our chargeback ratio calculator.

The takeaway

Card-not-present payments cost more because they're harder to verify and riskier for everyone involved. You can't avoid them if you sell online, but you can control how many of your transactions fall into the most expensive categories. Check your statement for keyed transactions, compare your provider's in-person, online and keyed rates, and use our processing fee calculator to see how your mix of in-person and online sales affects what you pay.

Provider rates quoted above were checked on each provider's official website on 3 November 2026 and can change. Always confirm current pricing with the provider.

Free quotes · No obligation

Get matched with the right processor

Two quick steps. We'll share your request with processing partners that fit your industry and volume, including high-risk specialists.

✓ Free for businesses
✓ High-risk industries welcome
✓ Compare offers before you commit
Step 1 of 2 · About your business
Please choose your industry and monthly sales.
Next: get my quotes →
Step 2 of 2 · Where should partners send quotes?
← Back
Thanks! Your request is in. A payments specialist from one of our partners will contact you about a quote.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.